回應耶證人「天堂經歷的假見證」﹕不能說100%都是假的

 

 

回應某耶和華見證人網友的「天空經歷的假見證」（http://www.douban.com/group/topic/71596133/）表示，有一些瀕死經歷中見到天堂（或地獄）的經歷是虛構的。 

 

同意！完全同意！ 

世界上的事物，凡有真的，便有假的。 

例如，有真基督教，便有假基督教（如耶和華見證人），有真聖經，便有假聖經（如《新世界》），所以瀕死經歷也有真有假。奇怪嗎？ 

 

 

某耶和華見證人網友說﹕「很多人濫用人們心中的信仰，以上帝之名來賺錢，而當人沒有讀過《聖經》，便會以為騙子說的沒有錯。如果基督徒需要尋求真理，讀《聖經》便已經足夠，由人所寫的著作不能保證永遠正確。」 

 

再次同意！ 

但是，聖經明說人死後靈魂仍存！例﹕

 

創 35:18 她將近于死，靈魂要走的時候，就給她兒子起名叫便俄尼

太 10:28 那殺身體不能殺靈魂的，不要怕他們。

路 8:55   她的靈魂便回來，她就立刻起來了。

徒 7:59   司提反呼籲主說，求主耶穌接收我的靈魂。

雅 2:26   身體沒有靈魂是死的，

 

所以今天若有瀕死經歷，知道自己的靈魂死後仍然存在，不奇怪。 

當然，我不相信所有報導，也不相信那些真實經歷的人的報導都是從神來的真理。 

但是，沒有人（除非已經被守望台洗腦）能否定全部，說100%都是假的。 

 

 

另一方面，曾經有醫院調查過這些經歷的真實性。下面是一個案例﹕

 

 

「The Science of Near-Death Experiences﹕Empirically investigating brushes with the afterlife」（http://www.theatlantic.com/features/archive/2015/03/the-science-of-near-death-experiences/386231/）

 

accounts of near-death experiences—or things that sound like them—date back at least to the Middle Ages, 瀕死經歷，自中世紀已有報導，and some researchers say to ancient times. 有說，自古已有The medical journalResuscitation recently published a brief account of the oldest known medical description of an NDE, written by an 18th-century French military doctor. 十八世紀的醫學日志已經有一份報告。But the modern era of research into near-death experiences is generally said to have begun in 1975. That was the year Raymond A. Moody Jr., a philosopher turned psychiatrist, published Life After Life, a book based on interviews with some 50 experiencers.

 

Moody’s book set off a steady stream of memoirs, TV shows, and articles. Since then, a small community has emerged of psychiatrists, psychologists, cardiologists, and other specialists. They share Moody’s belief that consciousness—the mind, the soul, call it what you will—may exist in some nonmaterial form, 莫遞相信感覺，無論你叫它做心靈、靈魂，人的非物質部分independent of but closely connected to the brain, 和大腦分開，雖然有關聯，and that NDEs may be able to provide evidence of it. 瀕死經歷證明了。The leading members of this coterie have distinguished careers at respectable universities and hospitals. They blurb one another’s books and give talks on spirituality and the nature of consciousness.

 

……

……

 

As a result, reports of veridical perception have a totemic significance among NDErs. One of the most celebrated is the story of “Maria,” a migrant worker who had an NDE 『馬利亞』在手術中經歷瀕死，during a cardiac arrest at a hospital in Seattle in 1977. She later told her social worker她後來告訴社會工作者 that while doctors were resuscitating her, she found herself floating outside the hospital building 她在醫院外邊and saw a tennis shoe on a third-floor window ledge, 看見三樓窗懸外有一只網球鞋which she described in some detail. 並詳細描寫。The social worker went to the window Maria had indicated, and not only found the shoe 這社會工作者後來找到此鞋，but said that the way it was placed meant there was no way Maria could have seen all the details she described from inside her hospital room.並說，因為鞋的位置，馬利亞不可能在醫院外邊看見。

 

 

 

維基百科也有一段﹕「Another argument made by several NDE researchers such as Parnia and Fenwick (2001) for the transcendental model is that the occurrence of anecdotal reports of patients being able to see and recall detailed events occurring during the cardiac arrest 病人在心臟停止時候看見和回想當時的細節that are afterwards verified by hospital staff 醫院員工查證為實supports the argument that such perception sometimes do occur during periods of clinical death. NDE researcher Janice Miner Holden found 107 一百零九份報導such anecdotal reports in the NDE literature as of 2009, out of which approximately 91% were accurate百分91準確。.^[132]」（http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Near-death_experience）

 

 

 

還有很多例子，所以，我們不能說，都是欺騙人的！

 

 

當某耶和華見證人網友說﹕「讀《聖經》便已經足夠」，是非常正確的，但必須讀誠實的聖經翻譯本，不是假貨《新世界》那種。